Skip to content

Heat Pump vs Gas Furnace Cost Calculator (US)

Yearly heating cost and CO2 of a gas furnace, heat pumps, dual fuel and electric resistance for 30 US cities, with EIA state prices.

United States

Your home and climate

5,974 heating degree days (base 65 °F) a year at O'Hare Intl AP (USW00094846), NOAA 1991–2020 normals.
Set to the city's state; change it if you live across a state line.
How to estimate your heating need
therms
Add up the therms on your last 12 bills (some bills show CCF: 1 CCF ≈ 1.037 therms).
%
The rest heats water and runs the range or dryer. A July bill × 12 is roughly your non-heating use.

Energy prices

$/therm
Default: EIA average residential price in Illinois, 2025 ($11.25 per Mcf ÷ 10.37). It is an all-in average including fixed charges, so your last therm costs a bit less.
¢/kWh
Default: EIA average residential price in Illinois, 2025. Use your own bill's price per kWh if you know it, including delivery.

Equipment

%
New condensing furnaces are 95–98%; ENERGY STAR furnaces in northern states are at least 95%. In bill mode the same AFUE converts the gas you burned into heat delivered.
Standard air-source heat pump
°F
Cold-climate air-source heat pump
°F
From the model's AHRI or NEEP cold-climate listing. ENERGY STAR cold-climate units need a COP of at least 1.75 at 5 °F. The dual-fuel system uses the standard heat pump's figures.
°F
At these prices the standard heat pump needs a COP of 4.56 to beat gas, more than it reaches at any temperature, so gas is cheaper to run all winter; the switchover then only matters for emissions.

Extra installed cost compared with a new gas furnace (optional)

$
$
$
$
Net of any state or utility rebate you expect. Leave empty to skip the payback.

Annual heating cost and emissions

Cheapest to run: Gas furnace
$734.40
For about 64.6 MMBtu (18,932 kWh) of heat a year
Lowest CO2: Cold-climate heat pump
2,994 lb
1.36 metric tons a year
Gas furnace ✓
$734.40 a year
680 therms
7,945 lb CO2 a year
Air-source heat pump
$1,285.44 a year
7,275 kWh
3,431 lb CO2 a year
Seasonal COP 2.6
1% of the heat from backup
Costs $551.04 a year more than gas
57% less CO2 than gas
Cold-climate heat pump
$1,121.51 a year
6,347 kWh
2,994 lb CO2 a year
Seasonal COP 2.98
Costs $387.11 a year more than gas
62% less CO2 than gas
Dual-fuel (heat pump + gas furnace)
$1,029.36 a year
4,674 kWh + 188 therms
4,406 lb CO2 a year
Seasonal COP 2.93
28% of the heat from backup
Costs $294.96 a year more than gas
45% less CO2 than gas
Electric resistance (baseboard)
$3,345.35 a year
18,932 kWh
8,930 lb CO2 a year
Costs $2,610.95 a year more than gas
12% more CO2 than gas
In Chicago, 1% of the heating load comes on days averaging below 5 °F and 0% below −13 °F (daily means; nights are colder).
Federal tax credits (checked 2026-11-13)
The 25C Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit, which covered heat pumps, applies only to property placed in service by December 31, 2025, and the 25D Residential Clean Energy Credit ended on the same date, so a 2026 or later installation gets neither (IRS). Rebates still exist through some state energy offices (DOE Home Energy Rebates) and many utilities. No amounts are included here: subtract what you will actually receive from the installed cost.
How this is calculated (and what it simplifies)

Each day's average temperature is modelled around the month's NOAA normal, with the day-to-day spread chosen so the total matches the station's official heating degree days. The heating need is spread over those temperatures in proportion to degree days.

A heat pump's COP is a straight line between its 47 °F and 5 °F ratings. Below its cut-off it stops and electric resistance strips (COP 1) take over; the dual-fuel system hands over to the furnace instead.

Simplifications: daily averages, not hourly temperatures (cold nights mean somewhat more backup than shown); the heat pump is sized to carry the house down to its cut-off; defrost is inside the COP figures; no maintenance or replacement costs. Gas CO2 is EPA's 5.3 kg (11.7 lb) per therm; electricity uses your state's eGRID2023 average generation rate, which is not the same as the marginal plant and leaves out grid losses.

In Canada? Use the Canadian heat pump vs gas furnace calculator.

Everything is calculated in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent anywhere. Browse all free tools.

Found a problem, or something that could be better? We read every message and we fix things quickly.

This heat pump vs gas furnace calculator for the US compares the yearly heating cost and CO2 of a gas furnace, a standard air-source heat pump, a cold-climate heat pump, a dual-fuel system and electric resistance heat for your home. Choose the nearest of 30 cities, from Phoenix and Los Angeles to Fargo and Anchorage, pick your state for prices and grid emissions, and describe your heating need: last year's therms, your square footage, or a load from an energy audit. For Canadian rules, units and prices, see the Canadian heat pump vs gas furnace calculator.

Default prices are EIA's 2025 state averages (gas converted from $/Mcf at 10.37 therms per Mcf, electricity from the Electric Power Annual), climate comes from NOAA's 1991–2020 normals, and grid CO2 from EPA's eGRID2023, the latest edition. All prices are editable, and your own bill is better than any average. The federal 25C tax credit does not apply to heat pumps placed in service after December 31, 2025, so no federal credit is assumed; state and utility rebates are linked, not guessed. This is an estimate for planning, not tax, financial or engineering advice.

How to use

  1. Choose the city with the climate closest to yours; the state and its average prices fill in.
  2. Pick how to estimate your heating need. Last year's therms are the most accurate, with the share used for space heating.
  3. Replace the state-average gas and electricity prices with the ones on your bills.
  4. Set the furnace AFUE and the heat pump COPs at 47 °F and 5 °F from the AHRI or NEEP listing of the models you are considering.
  5. Optionally enter each option's extra installed cost, net of rebates, for the payback.
  6. Compare yearly cost, CO2 and payback.

Frequently asked questions

Is a heat pump cheaper than a gas furnace?

Where gas is cheap and electricity expensive, usually not; where the reverse is true, usually yes. With EIA's 2025 averages, gas costs about $1.08 a therm in Illinois and $1.06 in Minnesota but $2.42 in Massachusetts and $2.46 in Florida, while electricity runs from about 12 ¢/kWh (Idaho, North Dakota) to over 30 ¢ (California, Massachusetts). A modern heat pump with a seasonal COP near 2.5 to 3 beats gas when electricity costs less than about 2.5 to 3 times the price of a kWh of gas heat. The calculator shows that break-even for your prices.

Can I still get the 25C tax credit for a heat pump in 2026?

No. The IRS says the Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit (25C) applies to qualifying improvements made through December 31, 2025; heat pumps placed in service after that date do not qualify. The Residential Clean Energy Credit (25D) also ended for property placed in service after December 31, 2025. Some states still offer Home Energy Rebates funded by the Department of Energy, and many utilities have their own rebates.

What is the best dual-fuel switchover temperature?

For lowest cost, switch to the furnace when the heat pump's COP drops below the ratio of your electricity price to your gas heat price. At 17.7 ¢/kWh and $1.08 per therm in a 95% furnace (Illinois averages), the heat pump only wins above a COP of about 4.5, which a standard unit reaches only in mild weather. In Massachusetts (30.4 ¢ and $2.42) the break-even COP is about 3.5. For lowest emissions, use the heat pump as long as it can carry the house.

How cold can a heat pump work?

Cold-climate heat pumps keep heating well below 0 °F. ENERGY STAR's cold-climate designation requires a COP of at least 1.75 at 5 °F and at least 70% of rated capacity at 5 °F; the NEEP specification is aimed at climate zone 4 and colder. Below the unit's cut-off, electric resistance strips or the furnace take over, which this calculator includes.

Does a heat pump reduce CO2 if my power comes from coal?

Usually still yes, but by less. Burning a therm of gas emits 5.3 kg (11.7 lb) of CO2. A 95% furnace gets about 27.8 kWh of heat from that therm; a heat pump at COP 2.5 needs about 11 kWh for the same heat, which at eGRID's US average of 767 lb/MWh is about 8.5 lb, roughly 27% less. In Vermont or Washington the cut is over 70%; in West Virginia or Wyoming, around 1,800 to 1,950 lb/MWh, a heat pump can emit more than a furnace. Electric resistance heat emits more than gas in most states.

Therms, kWh and COP: the arithmetic behind the comparison

A therm is 100,000 Btu, or 29.3 kWh of energy. In a 95% AFUE furnace it delivers 27.8 kWh of heat, so gas heat costs your gas price divided by 27.8 per kWh: $1.50 a therm is 5.4 ¢ per kWh of heat. A heat pump's heat costs the electricity price divided by its COP: 18 ¢/kWh at COP 3 is 6 ¢ per kWh of heat, at COP 2 it is 9 ¢.

COP changes with outdoor temperature, so the calculator spreads your yearly heating need over the temperatures your city actually sees. It models daily average temperatures around NOAA's monthly normals, with the spread fitted so the total matches the official heating degree days (for example 5,974 at Chicago O'Hare and 7,399 at Minneapolis-St. Paul).

Where the default prices come from

• Natural gas: EIA's 2025 average residential price by state in dollars per thousand cubic feet, divided by 10.37 therms per Mcf, as EIA recommends. EIA has no 2025 figure for Connecticut, Maine, Maryland, North Carolina, Rhode Island and South Carolina, so their 2024 price is used and labelled.

• Electricity: EIA Electric Power Annual 2025, average residential price by state.

• Both are averages of revenue over volume, so they include fixed monthly charges. Your last therm or kWh usually costs a little less than the average, so for the most accurate answer read the per-unit charges from your own bill.

• Grid CO2: EPA eGRID2023 (revision 2), state total output emission rates. eGRID2024 had not been published when we checked on November 13, 2026.

Federal incentives after 2025

The 25C Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit used to cover up to $2,000 a year for a qualifying heat pump. Under the current IRS guidance it covers only property placed in service by December 31, 2025, and the 25D clean energy credit ended on the same date. The DOE's Home Energy Rebates (HEEHR and HEAR) are run by state energy offices and are available only in some states; check your state energy office and your utility, and enter the cost after rebates in the payback fields.