Skip to content

Heat Pump vs Gas Furnace Cost Calculator (Canada)

Compare the yearly heating cost and CO2 of a gas furnace, standard and cold-climate heat pumps, hybrid and baseboard in 22 Canadian cities.

Canada

Your home and climate

3,751 heating degree-days below 18 °C a year at TORONTO PEARSON (AIRPORT) (ECCC normals 1991–2020).
How to estimate your heating need
m³
Add up your bills, or use the annual total some utilities print.
%
The rest heats water and runs the stove or dryer. Summer bills show it: summer m³ per month × 12 ÷ annual m³ is the non-heating share.

Energy prices (before GST/HST/PST)

¢/m³
Default: Enbridge Gas (EGD rate zone), rates from 2026-10-01. Supply, transport and delivery added together; your bill's per-m³ lines should add up to about this.
$/month
Customer or basic charge. Only matters if you would close the gas account.
¢/kWh
Default: average price at 1,000 kWh a month in Toronto, Hydro-Québec price comparison (rates of April 1, 2025). Use your own bill's price per kWh if you know it.

Equipment

%
New furnaces are 95–98%. Used for the gas option, the hybrid and, in bill mode, to work out the heat your current furnace delivered.
Standard air-source heat pump
°C
Cold-climate air-source heat pump
°C
From the model's NEEP or AHRI listing. ENERGY STAR cold-climate units have a COP of at least 1.75 at −15 °C. The hybrid uses the standard heat pump's figures.
°C
At these prices the standard heat pump needs a COP of 5.33 to beat gas, more than it reaches at any temperature, so gas is cheaper to run all winter; the switchover then only matters for emissions.

Extra installed cost compared with a new gas furnace (optional)

$
$
$
$
After any rebate you expect. Leave empty to skip the payback.

Annual heating cost and emissions

Cheapest to run: Gas furnace
$506.00
For about 17,324 kWh (62.4 GJ) of heat a year
Lowest emissions: Cold-climate heat pump
0.43 t
0.43 t CO2e a year
Gas furnace ✓
$506.00 a year
1,760 m³ of gas
3.4 t CO2e a year
Air-source heat pump
$1,061.33 a year
6,816 kWh
0.5 t CO2e a year
Seasonal COP 2.54
1% of the heat from backup
Costs $555.33 a year more than gas
85% less CO2e than gas
Cold-climate heat pump
$922.47 a year
5,925 kWh
0.43 t CO2e a year
Seasonal COP 2.92
Costs $416.47 a year more than gas
87% less CO2e than gas
Hybrid (heat pump + gas furnace)
$827.50 a year
4,430 kWh + 479 m³ of gas
1.25 t CO2e a year
Seasonal COP 2.85
27% of the heat from backup
Costs $321.50 a year more than gas
63% less CO2e than gas
Electric baseboard
$2,697.31 a year
17,324 kWh
1.27 t CO2e a year
Costs $2,191.31 a year more than gas
63% less CO2e than gas
In Toronto, 1% of the heating load comes on days averaging below −15 °C and 0% below −25 °C (daily means; nights are colder).
Carbon charge status (checked 2026-11-13)
The federal fuel charge on natural gas has been $0 since April 1, 2025 and was repealed by Bill C-4 (Royal Assent March 12, 2026), so none is included. B.C. eliminated its carbon tax on April 1, 2025. Quebec's cap-and-trade system still applies and is already inside Énergir's rate (8.727 ¢/m³ from October 1, 2026).
Rebates and loans: check the official pages
Programs open, close and change amounts often, so this calculator does not include any. Enter the cost after the rebate you expect in the payback fields. The Canada Greener Homes Grant and Loan are closed.
How this is calculated (and what it simplifies)

Each day's average temperature is modelled around the month's normal, with the day-to-day spread chosen so the total matches the station's official heating degree-days. The heating need is shared out over those temperatures in proportion to degree-days.

A heat pump's COP is a straight line between your two rated points. Below its cut-off it stops and electric resistance backup (COP 1) takes over; the hybrid hands over to the furnace instead.

Simplifications: daily averages, not hourly temperatures (cold nights mean somewhat more backup than shown); the heat pump is assumed big enough to cover the house down to its cut-off; defrost losses are inside the COP figures; no maintenance, replacement or financing costs. Gas emissions use the National Inventory Report factor (about 1.93 kg CO2e per m³); electricity uses your province's grid average, not the marginal power plant.

Comparing in the US? Use the US heat pump vs gas furnace calculator. In Ontario, the Ontario electricity bill calculator shows which price plan suits running a heat pump.

Sources (all checked 2026-11-13)
Estimates only, not financial or engineering advice. Prices change; check your own bills and the official sources above. A heating contractor's load calculation is what sizes real equipment.

Everything is calculated in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent anywhere. Browse all free tools.

Found a problem, or something that could be better? We read every message and we fix things quickly.

This heat pump vs gas furnace calculator for Canada estimates what it costs to heat your home for a year with a gas furnace, a standard air-source heat pump, a cold-climate heat pump, a hybrid (heat pump plus furnace) system or electric baseboard, and how much CO2e each one emits. Pick the nearest of 22 cities from Victoria to Yellowknife, then describe your heating need the most reliable way you can: last year's gas use from your bills, your floor area, or a heating load from an EnerGuide or energy audit. For US rules, units and prices, see the US heat pump vs gas furnace calculator.

The answer depends almost entirely on three things: how cold your winters are, the ratio of your electricity price to your gas price, and how well the heat pump performs in the cold. Climate comes from Environment and Climate Change Canada's 1991–2020 normals; default gas rates come from each province's main gas utility and electricity prices from Hydro-Québec's comparison of major cities, all dated and editable; grid emissions come from Canada's National Inventory Report. The federal fuel charge is $0 since April 1, 2025, so none is included. It is an estimate for planning, not engineering or financial advice, and it links to rebate programs instead of assuming any amount.

How to use

  1. Choose the city with the climate closest to yours. Default prices for that province fill in.
  2. Pick how to estimate your heating need. Gas bills are the most accurate: enter last year's m³ and the share used for space heating.
  3. Check the gas and electricity prices against your own bills and correct them if they differ.
  4. Adjust the furnace AFUE and the heat pump COP figures to match the models you are considering, and the hybrid's switchover temperature.
  5. Optionally enter how much more each option costs to install than a new furnace, after rebates, to see the payback.
  6. Compare the yearly cost, CO2e and payback of each system.

Frequently asked questions

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace in Canada?

It depends on your province's prices more than on the weather. With the default prices on November 13, 2026, a heat pump is clearly cheaper than gas in Quebec, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia, where gas costs 64 to 102 ¢/m³ and (in Quebec) electricity is cheap. In Ontario and the Prairies gas is cheap (16 to 29 ¢/m³), so gas usually stays cheaper to run, and a hybrid system that uses gas only on the coldest days comes closest. In B.C. the heat pump usually comes out somewhat cheaper. Enter your own rates, because the result flips easily.

Do heat pumps work at −25 °C?

Cold-climate air-source heat pumps keep running to about −25 °C or lower, at a COP of roughly 1.5 to 2 in that range. Natural Resources Canada says newer models have low-temperature cut-offs between −15 °C and −25 °C. ENERGY STAR's cold-climate criterion requires a COP of at least 1.75 at −15 °C (5 °F). Below the cut-off, backup heat (electric resistance or your furnace) takes over, which this calculator models.

What is a good switchover temperature for a hybrid heat pump?

The money-saving switchover is the temperature at which the heat pump's COP falls to the price ratio of electricity to gas heat. The calculator works it out for your prices: if electricity costs 15.6 ¢/kWh and gas 28.75 ¢/m³ in a 95% furnace, a heat pump is cheaper only when its COP is above about 5.3, which is rare; so for running cost alone gas wins most of the time in Ontario, and a lower switchover mainly cuts emissions. In Quebec the ratio favours the heat pump at almost any temperature.

Is there still a carbon tax on natural gas?

No federal one. The fuel charge rate was set to zero from April 1, 2025, and Bill C-4, which received Royal Assent on March 12, 2026, permanently removed the consumer carbon price. B.C. eliminated its own carbon tax on April 1, 2025. Quebec's cap-and-trade system still adds a cost to gas, 8.727 ¢/m³ on Énergir's rate from October 1, 2026, which is included in the Quebec default price.

Are there heat pump rebates in Canada?

Programs exist but change often, so this calculator does not include any amounts. The Canada Greener Homes Grant and Loan are closed. The federal government announced a National Heat Pump Rebate in October 2026, and several provinces run their own programs, such as Ontario's Home Renovation Savings and Hydro-Québec's LogisVert. The page links to the official sites; subtract the rebate you expect from the installed cost before reading the payback.

How much CO2 does switching from gas to a heat pump save?

Burning a cubic metre of natural gas emits about 1.93 kg CO2e. Where electricity is nearly carbon-free, as in Quebec, Manitoba, B.C. and Newfoundland and Labrador, a heat pump cuts heating emissions by well over 90%. In Ontario (73 g CO2e/kWh in 2024) the cut is still large. In Alberta, Saskatchewan and Nova Scotia, where the grid is 350 to 630 g/kWh, savings are smaller and baseboard heat can emit more than gas.

Why the answer is different in every province

A heat pump moves heat instead of making it, so each kWh of electricity delivers two to four kWh of heat, depending on the outdoor temperature. A furnace turns about 95% of the gas's energy into heat. Which is cheaper therefore comes down to the price of a kWh of electricity divided by the COP, against the price of a kWh of gas heat.

Default prices in the calculator (before tax, checked November 13, 2026):

• Natural gas, all per-m³ charges: Alberta (ATCO Gas South with the regulated rate) about 16 ¢, Manitoba 22 ¢, Saskatchewan 24 ¢, Ontario (Enbridge, EGD zone) 29 ¢, B.C. (FortisBC) 47 ¢, Quebec (Énergir) 64 ¢, New Brunswick 80 ¢, Nova Scotia 102 ¢, plus a fixed monthly charge of $13 to $37.

• Electricity at 1,000 kWh a month: Montréal 8.3 ¢, Winnipeg 10.5 ¢, Vancouver 12.6 ¢, Ottawa 14.4 ¢, Toronto 15.6 ¢, St. John's 15.6 ¢, Moncton 16.6 ¢, Regina 17.9 ¢, Charlottetown 19.7 ¢, Halifax 20.5 ¢, Edmonton 22.0 ¢, Calgary 22.9 ¢ (Hydro-Québec comparison, rates of April 1, 2025, excluding taxes).

Alberta's very cheap gas and expensive electricity make a heat pump hard to justify on running cost there, while in Quebec and the Maritimes it is the cheaper heat almost all winter.

How cold-weather performance is modelled

Monthly average temperatures hide the cold snaps where a heat pump struggles, so the calculator models each day's average temperature around the month's normal. The spread is chosen so that the total matches the station's official heating degree-days below 18 °C (for example 3,751 at Toronto Pearson, 4,434 at Ottawa and 5,672 at Winnipeg). The heating need is then shared over those temperatures.

The heat pump's COP is a straight line through two rated points, 8.3 °C and −15 °C (47 °F and 5 °F, the AHRI and ENERGY STAR test temperatures). Below the cut-off it stops and electric backup at COP 1 takes over; a hybrid hands over to the furnace instead. This uses daily averages, so it slightly understates backup use on cold nights, and it assumes the heat pump is sized to carry the house down to its cut-off.

Getting an accurate heating load from your gas bills

Your gas use is a measurement of your actual house, so it beats any estimate from floor area. Add up the m³ on twelve months of bills. Then remove what was not space heating: multiply an average summer month's use by 12, divide by the annual total, and subtract that share. With a gas water heater this is often a noticeable share; your summer bills tell you yours.

The calculator multiplies the heating gas by 0.0373 GJ per m³ (the Canada Energy Regulator's conversion factor) and by your furnace's efficiency to get the heat your house actually needed. Different equipment then has to deliver that same heat.