Skip to content

Traditional vs Roth Calculator (US): IRA & 401(k)

Compare fully deductible Traditional and qualified Roth retirement scenarios in the US.

United States

Found a problem, or something that could be better? We read every message and we fix things quickly.

Traditional vs Roth calculator (US) compares a fully deductible pre-tax contribution with an eligible Roth contribution.

It uses IRS annual IRA/401(k) reference caps for 2022–2027 and your own tax-saving rate. You must verify compensation, MAGI, workplace coverage, plan rules and remaining capacity; the calculator does not determine eligibility.

How to use

  1. Choose the contribution year, IRA or 401(k), age and relevant prior-employer wages.
  2. Enter verified fully deductible and Roth capacities, net budget, personal tax-saving rate and retirement assumptions.
  3. Confirm eligibility and compare same-net-cost outcomes; review any high-wage Roth catch-up restriction.

Frequently asked questions

Does this determine IRA deduction eligibility?

No. MAGI, filing status, compensation and workplace coverage can reduce deductions or direct Roth eligibility. Enter verified eligible capacities; nondeductible IRA basis and conversions are excluded.

What changes at age 60–63?

Some 401(k) plans permit a higher catch-up in these years starting in 2025. The reference cap reflects published limits, but your plan must offer the feature and your compensation must support it.

Can higher earners deduct all catch-up contributions?

For 2026–2027, qualifying higher prior-year employer wages can require catch-up contributions to be Roth. That catch-up is excluded from this fully pre-tax scenario’s capacity.

Are the 2027 limits available?

Yes. IRS Notice 2026-66 publishes 2027 limits. The selector labels 2027 as planning, while the default remains 2026.

Annual caps are shared limits

Traditional and Roth IRAs share their annual contribution limit; pre-tax and designated Roth 401(k) deferrals share the relevant employee limit. Subtract existing contributions before entering capacity; the two strategies are alternatives, not simultaneous allowances.

Qualified withdrawals and tax assumptions

The comparison assumes fully taxable pre-tax withdrawals and qualified tax-free Roth withdrawals. Early distributions, Roth five-year rules, employer matching, state-specific deductions and future marginal-tax changes require separate analysis.